Claim in Everyday science myths
Lightning never strikes the same place twice.
Verdict: refuted
Evidence for
None yet.
Evidence against
“Lightning often strikes the same place repeatedly”
Note: NWS Lightning Myths page, paragraph 61; the Empire State Building example is in the same paragraph.
“Yes. Lightning can strike the same place twice. In fact, lightning often strikes the same place repeatedly, especially a tall, pointy, isolated object.”
Note: CDC lightning FAQ.
“Lightning does strike the same place twice.”
Note: Independent .edu source (West Texas A&M physics) stating lightning does strike the same place twice.